Civil Rights

Attorney Paul J Sulla involved in Real Property Theft

Attorney Paul J Sulla involved in Real Property Theft

Screen Shot 2016-03-26 at 12.09.38 AM Open Letter by Investigative Journalist Sherri Kane, as a Victim of Attorney Paul J. Sulla, Jr.’s Property Theft Scheme

My domestic partner Leonard G. Horowitz and I, are victims of non-judicial foreclosure fraud, mortgage fraud, illegal transfers of our mortgages and notes, and theft of our real property and title by organized crime.

Our case involves Attorney Paul J. Sulla Jr and his shill, Jason Hester, with the complicity of Attorney Stephen D. Whittaker of Kona, HI.

Mr. Whittaker has lied and perjured himself and has hoodwinked Judge Ronald Ibarra and his subordinate Judge Melvin Fujino to grant our 17 acre property to a homeless drifter named Jason Hester, who Mr. Whittaker claims to be representing. Mr. Whittaker, however, is being paid by the concealed real party of interest, Paul J. Sulla Jr. Mr. Hester is being used as a shill for this drug dealing attorney Sulla, who illegally manufactures and traffics drugs within a racketeering enterprise operating on the Big Island of Hawaii.

Sulla runs an illegal ayahuasca (dimethyltryptamice, DMT-Schedule I, narcotic) “church” north of Hilo, on the Hamakua coast. This is a “religious front” that strong evidence and multiple affidavits from victims and witnesses indicates is a money laundering operation.

In our case, Mr. Sulla made Mr. Hester the supposed “Overseer” of another sham “church.” Sulla used Hester to stay an “arms length” away from being discovered and being liable. Hester is judgment proof, and has a criminal record. Sulla has used Hester to steal our 17 acres of land, plus a large house that we purchased as a “Bed & Breakfast.” But that “commercial property” could never be used commercially due to the fraud in the sale and continuous lawsuits Mr. Sulla and his so called “clients” have waged against us since 2005. The fraud in the sale of the property was committed by Sulla’s personal representative–the seller, also a convicted felon, Cecil Loran Lee.

Mr. Sulla was disqualified in our case, and in other cases. He was publicly censured by the Supreme Court of Hawaii for “reckless arguing.” Sulla was disqualified in our U.S District court case, so Sulla could no longer represent Hester. So Sulla hired and paid for another attorney, Whittaker, who apparently you pay a fee to and he gets the job done!

Mr. Sulla has been wearing many hats in our cases against him, including attorney, auctioneer, debt collector, “church” trustee, Hester’s fiduciary, etc. Sulla even gave Hester a 50K “loan” on paper to end up with our Property. (See exhibits below.) Sulla knew Hester would never pay back this “loan” so Sulla would be able for foreclose on the property (again, for a third time!)

paul_sulla_leaves_scene_of_foreclosure_crimeSulla and his “clients” have foreclosed on our property twice already. While the first foreclosure case was still happening, Sulla foreclosed non-judicially on the same property. The first judicial foreclosure case is on appeal after a Fifth Amended Final Judgment (i.e., the 6th Final Judgment) was issued by Judge Ronald Ibarra. In that case, after the jury awarded us $200K for Lee’s fraud in the sale, the judge “vacated” our jury award. In other words, after nearly five years of litigating and losing more than $3M in damages, my partner, Leonard, beat Lee’s frivolous judicial foreclosure, only to have Ibarra give Horowitz nothing but another seven years of heartache. Leonard won the jury award for fraud in the sale of the property, as well as a denial of foreclosure since Leonard had paid all the money when it became due. This is even ruled in the Fifth Amended Final Judgment, but the same Judge Ibarra gave Sulla nearly everything Sulla asked him for, including substituting Hester as a “sham plaintiff” to take the place of Lee, after Lee died. Then Sulla was able to bring another case against Leonard and I without even appealing the first case! That first case is still open. And then, when Leonard and I went to court to defend our property in the second case, Sulla schemed to block our “standing” to plead in our defense. This is a violation of our 14th Amendment rights to due process. It also violated res judicata, and many laws. But the judges ignored tons of “material” facts and evidence, to grant Sulla a summary judgment, giving away our title to Hester (really Sulla.)

Ibarra signed the 5th amended final judgment in (Civ. No. 05-1-0196) after Ibarra signed the conflicting final judgment in case No. 14-1-0304.) We believe these conflicting final judgments are simply a ploy to confjune 10

use everything and everyone to give Sulla our property. The reason for the 5th amended final judgment is Judge Ibarra kept violating Jenkins in the “first filed” supposedly “controlling” case. Not having given us an appealable judgment kept the conflict going, so that Sulla could move through the 2nd case and get a Writ of Ejectment.

We have been dealing with these kinds of judicial corruption and fraud upon the court since 2008. After Leonard prevailed in the original case, as mentioned, the nightmare was supposed to have ended. Instead Lee and Sulla evaded service and broke the law requiring them to release our mortgage. Judge Ibarra then allowed Sulla to overturn our jury award. Then Sulla, Ibarra and Whittaker violated our rights by not allowing our “standing” to plead in defense of our interests.

Where in history have you heard of a Fifth Amended Final Judgement or a 6th Final Judgement? You can’t find one in Google Scholar. It doesn’t exist among more than a million cases listed.

Also we have another parallel case before the U.S. District Court, on Judge Seabright’s desk, involving the same parties. (Sulla and Hester are the defendants.) There too Sulla and Hester are being accused of violating our civil rights. Judge Seabright put that case on administrative hold pending what happens in 0304 and 0196. Now he is having to consider opening the case again due to the fiasco and “void” judgment that came out of the 0304 court.

In the two current competing circuit court cases, our attorney is Big Island County Councilwoman Margaret Wille. Ms. Wille is attempting to diplomatically let the court know that injustice and fraud upon the court is happening in our case. She has informed the courts about Mr. Sulla’s proven forgeries, and his false claims that Hester was an heir to the seller, Lee. You would think that the judges would have pause after Margaret let them know about Sulla’s fraudulent filings, but the complete opposite is occurring.

It appears that the judges have been hoodwinked because they continue allowing Sulla to maliciously prosecute us, without being added as a real party of interest. The judges have remained willfully blind to the fact that Sulla has fraudulently transferred our mortgage, notes, and title to sham entities he made parties. The judges have denied us a trial, to prevent the case being heard on it’s merits. This is in disregard of the original case 0196, where the same judge Ibarra ordered Leonard to pay the final balloon payment, which he did. The judge then allowed the case to continue with several more amended final judgments by Sulla. With each “final judgment” Ibarra changed the “findings of facts” and took more and more away from us. We have been completely railroaded and defrauded by Sulla and his co-conspirators. Ms. Wille thankfully stepped in recently to hopefully stop this insanity.

There are many other victims of Sulla coming forward at this time. One has even claimed that Sulla was involved in murdering her elderly father who lived in Kauai. She alleges that Sulla stole the man’s nest egg that was to have been given to his children’s after he died. But Sulla came in and placed the family’s inheritance into a trust Sulla created.

The prosecutors on the Big Island and Kauai have remain willfully blind to all the mounting evidence. Prosecutor Mitch Roth knows all about Sulla but doesn’t want to rock any boats as though he is either afraid of the drug mob, or being bribed to remain willfully blind to aid and abet the crimes.

Our current State cases on appeal include 14-1-0304, and 05-1-0196, both in the Third Circuit Court, Hawaii

We also have a pending grand jury investigation now open that includes the aforementioned judges, Roth, the named attorneys, and others on other islands. We are currently waiting to receive a summons to testify.

We have also pleaded for an FBI investigation.

Please see the filings linked below from our attorney Margaret Wille for the latest hearing Feb 26, 2016, opposed by Judge Melvin Fujino who had his decision written up before we arrived in court. We know this because he read a lengthy statement prepared prior to the hearing.

Also included are the latest filings by Ms Wille for another attempt to stay our case. As of now Sulla and Whittaker are railroading us in violation of due process in the hopes they can get this done before any in authority sees their crimes.  Judge Fujino just railroaded Ms. Wille, as Ibarra and also Judge Strance had done to us. Fujino allowed Whittaker to commit perjury and lie to the court, as we have now evidence of in court transcripts we purchased at great expense. Ibarra appears to be protecting another judge, Leonard’s first attorney Glenn Hara of Stanley Roehrig’s lawfirm, Roehrig, Roehrig, Wilson & Hara.

Judge Glenn Hara committed malpractice in the 0196 case. There was evidence tampering, witness tampering and obstruction of justice happening before and during the trial in 0196. We are holding clear and convincing records of this as well.

Most incredibly, no court has ever questioned sham plaintiff Hester’s standing. The burden is on the plaintiff to prove his standing and legal interest in title, but not in our case. This is a violation of case law, including Deutsche Bank vs The Williamses.

Linked below is also Sulla’s sham corporation paperwork. He created the “Gospel of Believers” “foreclosing mortgagee” using forged and altered documents. He then used the fake “church” to conduct his illegal auction/non-judicial foreclosure of our property (These actions violated Hawaii Revised Statutes 667-5, 651-c, 480-2; 480D, and 485 laws, among many others.) Sulla made many obvious blunders, that the courts ignored. For example, the fake corporation did not legally exist yet when Sulla transferred our mortgage and note into it. Also, Sulla included forged signatures, copied and pasted signatures of the Seller Lee, who was on his death bed in Arizona when Sulla claimed Lee went before a Hawaii notary. Dates were obviously altered on these records. A simple examination of the photocopied pages 6 and 8 of the Articles of Incorporation for the “Gospel of Believers” reveals Sulla altered the dates by adding a “2” before the number “8” to falsely allege the 28th was when Lee signed, even though Lee was thousands of miles away and dying on that date. The fake Articles of Incorporation for the “foreclosing mortgagee” also names “Gwen Hillman” (who is Lee’s sister) as a “scribe” for the fake “church.”  But instead of where she is supposed to sign, there is the same forged signature of Lee, pasted there with the date showing the “8” not “28.” These “official records” that we obtained from the State’s DCCA are so messed up any fool can see these are “altered” and illegal documents. Yet, Third Circuit Court Judges Ibarra, Strance, and Fujino accepted this fake instrument and then gave away title to our property in service to the criminals.

Also attached is the notarized document by a forensic handwriting expert, Beth Chrisman, verifying what I am saying here–Sulla’s forgeries of that sham incorporation paperwork.  Ms. Chrisman is willing to testify as a witness to the altered signatures.

Two years later, on June 14, 2011,  Sulla transferred our title into Hester’s personal name and gave Hester a 50K mortgage on paper. That contract states (in paragraph 3)  that if Hester doesn’t pay property taxes, then Sulla can foreclose on him. Sulla knew full well that a homeless drifter could not afford to pay almost $6-10k a year in property taxes.

We are currently on a payment plan with the county tax office to pay the taxes since our name has been illegally transferred off the tax records, into Hester’s name. We are making payments of $250 per month to avoid having the property go to auction. Sulla made one tax payment right before Ibarra unlawfully granted him summary judgment. Before Sulla had illegally transferred our notes and mortgage, we had all of our taxes paid up to date.

Sulla also falsely claimed that Hester was the seller’s nephew and a rightful heir, but we hired Christopher Baker’s Private Investigation Service to check this out. (See attached.) Baker discovered that Hester had no blood relation to the seller Lee. So then Sulla changed his claim and said that Hester was Lee’s grandnephew, and again this was false.

Attached is a letter placed into the Federal court corroborating the above evidence that Sulla’s church created for supposedly Hester was fraudulent. These two letters were written by seller Lee’s criminal cohorts–Herbert M. Ritke and his son Ronn Ritke. These two men were attempting to get out of being sued by us for their complicity in the fraud and theft. Sulla used the Ritkes’ address to claim that was the address of the fake church that, supposedly, Lee formed in order to steal our property. When the heat got turned up, the Ritke’s threw Hester under the bus, especially since Lee is now deceased.

Also Seller Lee was a known forger and felon, and Sulla knew that from court records and Horowitz’s correspondence. Lee had a 85K federal lien on the property for growing marijuana, and he even had a landing strip next to the property to get the pot off island. Before Leonard came along Lee attempted to sell the same property to Philip Maise and his domestic partner by fraud. Maise won nearly $225K in two lawsuits against Lee for fraud. Lee attempted to extort Leonard after Leonard agreed to allow Lee to take 85K out of escrow to pay what Lee referred to as a “high interest loan,” omitting the fact that it was money to pay off the government’s lien.

By the time Leonard figured out he was being extorted by Lee, he already had too much money invested in the property to pull out of the deal.

Leonard’s mortgage payments to Lee were eventually garnished by Judge Nakamura, and ordered to be paid to Maise. Leonard had a $550K title insurance policy on the property, with Island title company arranged through Stewart Title Company. Island Title Co. was complicit in this crime, because they knew Maise and Lee were in legal battle, but they failed to disclose Leonard that Maise had already encumbered the property when Lee sold the property “free from encumbrances.” Stewart Title Co. then denied coverage. They breached their contract and blamed Leonard for losing the title!

Island Title Co. acted as though they were part of a crime syndicate. It seems as though they set Leonard up to go down. They not only concealed Lee’s encumbrance on the property; cause after all, Lee arranged to have Island Title Co. administer escrow and the money,  but Island Title Co.  referred Leonard to Glenn Hara, an Attorney of Stanley Roehrig’s lawfirm, Roehrig, Roehrig, Wilson & Hara became Judge Glenn Hara, because they wanted the money from the sale. So Leonard went to Attorney Glenn Hara for Hara to draft what he titled, “The Agreement for Closing Escrow.” Glenn Hara drafted this document by dictating to Leonard precisely what the Agreement should say, and Leonard wrote it down verbatim. Beforehand, Glenn Hara reviewed all the problematic closing agreements, and his handwriting was all over those original files (attached). The Agreement for Closing Escrow should have been called “Addendum to the Mortgage.” That malpractice cost Leonard a lot of money, because of the fiasco at trial, when Glenn Hara made a secret agreement with Leonard’s lawyer, John S. Carroll, not to show up as a witness, and also conceal ” The Glenn Hara File.” All that became problems for Leonard when Lee altered that agreement, and cut and pasted signatures on the altered document that omitted Leonard’s indemnification clause. Lee altered the Agreement so that he could foreclose, keep Leonard’s money, and get the property back as well.

Because Glenn Hara is so heavily involved in the evidence tampering, witness tampering, and obstruction of justice, Ibarra had cause to protect his subordinate judge ruling outrageously and consistently against Leonard.  This enabled Sulla to walk all over us.

That Agreement for Closing Escrow was written to protect Leonard by stating that Lee could only foreclose if Leonard did not make timely mortgage payments, which Leonard did do; and that “certified true original Agreement, of course, remained at the title company.

But no matter! Lee contacted the property insurance company and had Leonard’s policy cancelled, which he could not revive, because Lee had arranged the “residential” policy, and Lee reported Horowitz was using it commercially; and you could not get commercial property insurance in a “Lava Flow Zone One. So Lee knew he had Leonard stuck between a rock and a hard place.

So Lee knew Leonard was no longer protected against a foreclosure suit after Lee altered the Agreement and had the insurance cancelled. He then submitted his altered agreement to the court claiming Leonard had altered the altered one! Yes. You got that right. Lee claimed that the certified true original Agreement for Closing Escrow was the forgery! And because Carroll and Glenn Hara plotted to conceal ” The Glenn Hara file,” and not summons Glenn Hara to testify, they all set Leonard up to have the jury rule in Lee’s favor on that claim of fraud.

Island Title Co. officials simply said they could not recall what happened to cause the certified true original Agreement to become the fake! This appears to be how the real estate and drug mob works on the Big Island of Hawaii to steal people’s properties, and fix trials.

Leonard went through a jury trial that appears to have been rigged also by the most outspoken juryman later being found to have attempted to buy the property immediately after they returned a verdict only marginally in Leonard’s favor. (See attached Letter to Hara) The juryman was “Uncle Lewis Strada”–the uncle of Gia Rose-Strada, who worked for Leonard as a caretaker, but had no idea her uncle was in on a sting to damage Leonard. (Yes. this was totally bizarre.)

Mr. Strada had an interest in buying the property and attempted to purchase it through a local real estate agent, Dianna Shomer, immediately after the jury was dismissed. The jury claimed that Leonard’s version of the Agreement–the certified true original one held by Island Title Co., did not damage Lee, so there was no money awarded for Leonard’s alleged alteration of that document. The  jury went one to award Leonard $200k due to Lee’s fraud in the sale of the property.

Nevertheless, Leonard was devastated the jury could claim he forged a document when the original was with the title office, Lee’s fake had a missing witnesses’ signatures on it, and the Court knew that Lee had been a convicted felon, and even had Judge Nakamura in the same Third Circuit Court under Judge Ibarra rule that Lee had altered MANY documents in his case against Maise.

Thankfully, Judge Ibarra denied foreclosure and Leonard prevailed in Civ. No. 05-1-0196. Then Ibarra ordered Leonard to pay the final balloon payment which Leonard did on February 27, 2009. Leonard applied the $200k jury award as directed by Attorney Carroll, and then paid an additional $154k by checks and wire transfers. So the final payment was paid, and Leonard thought it was all over, and he could go on with his life. But the nightmare had only just begun.

Several months later, Ibarra allowed Sulla, while Lee was on his death bed, to file a rediculously “untimely” “motion for a judgment as a matter of law” to revoke Leonard’s jury award. This Motion was supposed to be filed before the jury went into deliberation. But instead, Ibarra permitted it to, apparently, to cause Lee’s and Sulla’s victim to be further damaged. Leonard has been trying to appeal that jury award ever since 2009, but Ibarra kept issuing non-appealable judgments according to Jenkins requirements; so the appellate court kept sending the case back to Ibarra for new “final judgments”.

Lee never left a Will and Sulla never appealed the foreclosure denied ruling, but instead Sulla found a transient shill, Jason Hester, that Sulla could use as a sham heir to claim Leonard still owed the jury award amount. Normally, if there is a “deficiency” in mortgage payments, the person owed the money can simply motion the court for a “deficiency judgment.” But Sulla’s scheme needed to conceal that fact that he, and Lee, had evaded notices that the final balloon payment had been made, and to release the mortgage as required by Hawaii law HRS § 506-8. Sulla also needed to conceal his bigger scheme of fraudulently transferring the paid-off mortgage and note into a sham “church” that would soon take the place of the dying Lee.

Real Estate Enterprise Chart



After Sulla substituted THE OFFICE OF OVERSEER, A CORPORATE SOLE AND ITS SUCCESSOR, OVER AND FOR THE POPULAR ASSEMBLY OF REVITALIZE, A GOSPEL OF BELIEVERS. (You would not believe this is the real name, but it is. Let’s just call it “GOB”), Sulla claimed that Leonard owed GOB $200.000 on the void mortgage, and would be foreclosed upon non-judicially if Leonard did not pay. (That’s called “extortion.”) And when Leonard refused to bend, Sulla committed the illegal NJF foreclosure auction on the court steps in violation of HRS §§ 667-5; 651-C; 480-2; 480D; and 485. This was how Sulla sold our house to Hester, the alleged “Overseer” of the fake GOB.

We hired attorney Attorney Gary Dubin to stop Sulla’s auction, but Dubin took our money and did nothing to block Sulla’s NJF. We did film and produce a news segment on Sulla’s illegal auction, and you can view this HERE 

We went back to Dubin about how he neglected his duty, and he simply claimed that “possession was 9/10ths of the law” and said not to worry.

Then Sulla used Hester to attempt to evict us in the lower district court and we went back to Dubin again and complained that this now happened as a consequence of Dubin’s inaction or negligence. Dubin told us to pay a total of $26K, or we would most certainly lose that case. Dubin then had one of his subordinates, Benjamin Brower, take our case. Brower and Dubin started making back room deals with Sulla. (We have e-mails to confirm this.) Brower and Dubin claimed that Sulla wanted an extension since he was “new” to the case, which everyone but the judge knew was a lie. We never agreed to that “continuance,” and it should have stopped there. But it didn’t. So we complained to Gary Dubin again, and Dubin allegedly fired Brower. Dubin then sent us a part time judge, Peter Stone, who put in a great filing and the case was instantly dismissed. (See attached quote about Sulla from Peter Stone. The full filing by Stone available upon request.)

Sulla also attempted to serve us ejectment warrants by posting them on our gate. There were 5 day notices to vacate. He used another attorney’s stationary, and  conducted a forgery of a process server’s signature on the documents. We hired handwriting expert Beth Chrisman who confirmed that this was Sulla’s dirty work.

Leonard and I are journalists so we had been documenting everything that was happening, and Sulla was very unhappy about that


Sulla:Lee Trust Scheme Graphic








Around that time, in 2012, we learned about Sulla’s drug church, and that he had acquired over 50 properties, and used them to launder his drug money. According to a Federal Tax Investigator who contacted us for information about Sulla after Sulla was named in a Superseding Indictiment of Hawaii arms dealer, Art Ong, and the U.S. Treasury Dept. was investigating, Derick Tabania appeared on our radar screen. Tabania explained that Sulla appears to be involved in a pattern of creating and administering what Tabania called  a “Vertical Abusive Trust Beneficiary Scheme.” That’s how Sulla always remains an arms length away from any corporation or trust that he creates, the tax investigator explained.

Sulla also promotes on his website blog that he assists people who are victims of mortgage or foreclosure fraud, while he himself is engaged in committing it. This shows his psychopathic “condition of mind.”

At one point, Sulla started getting heat from people, so he decided to sue us for defamation. That case went before another one of Judge Ibarra’s subordinate judges’ in the Third Circuit–Judge Elizabeth Strance. (She is no longer on the bench, because the Judicial Selection Committee had apparently received so many complaints about her, they decided to now renew her contract.) Leonard and I filed a counter complaint against Sulla containing more than a dozen counter-claims. Nonetheless, Judge Strance violated our rights and made us take down for almost 3 years.

Judge Strance ordered us to mediation with Sulla, which was a farce.  We decided on a retired judge as the mediator. Judge Amano started requesting that Hester come forward for questioning, but of course Sulla blocked that from happening, and made up lame excuses for why Hester would not be available.

Sulla never intended for us to make it to trial, and has always avoided any trial with us. So 6 weeks before the trial in the defamation case, in a hearing that Sulla did not attend, Judge Strance removed her judicial robe, came off the bench, and sat down with us, telling us she wanted to dismiss the case. then told Judge Strance we were all prepared to go to trial. Leonard had even prepared a Powerpoint presentation to show the jury. Then we asked about our counterclaims and Judge Strance then delivered a SHOCKER! Judge Strance claimed she “lost” all of our Counterclaims. Lost them? We had submitted them three times, and we have records of each filing. How could Judge Elizabeth A. Strance’s Court have lost our counterclaims? Stance had no explanation, but was apologetic. She said she would look for them, and get back to us. A few days later she informed us that we had no counterclaims, and that since we had nothing to gain by going to trial, we should just drop the case. That is how we prevailed in Civ. No. 12-1-0417.

What is interesting is that Judge Strance, when she sat with us, she told us that she believed us. She believed everything we claimed about Sulla, including him stealing our property. Judge Strance had witnessed Sulla testifying and covering-up his drug church operations. Sulla actually pled the 5th Amendment right not to answer. (That is called a “negative averment” or “adverse inference;” which should have been taken very seriously by any judge.)

In retrospect, we believe that the Third Circuit Court officials knew we were going to slam dunk Sulla at trial, and they pressed Judge Strance to dismiss the case so as not to air Sulla’s dirty laundry.

A few months earlier,  Sulla had summoned us for a settlement meeting, and when we showed up, it was a set up. Sulla had a process server serve us with another eviction complaint in the same lower district court that we had already defeated the same complaint with the help of Peter Stone. That State district court had no jurisdiction over title matters. Hester was also present, but was told by Sulla not to speak. Sulla then extorted Leonard again, and said he could make this all disappear if we paid them $375K.  (That extortion was being recorded, we later learned, by one of our friends.) We of course told him and Hester that they were not entitled to any money; that we had already paid for our property, and even if there was any money due, neither he nor Hester was entitled to it. (Recording available on request.)

After Leonard filed counterclaims for malicious prosecution, malpractice and contempt of court, Sulla then attempted to dismiss the lower court’s case he had filed to get us evicted. Judge Freitas ordered that Sulla file in the proper court or he would be made to go to trial on Leonard’s counterclaims.

That is when Sulla filed Civ. No. 14-1-0304, “Hester’s” quiet title case.

Sulla again claimed that we had not paid the $200k left on the note since our jury award was unlawfully vacated because of him. We had been trying to get an appealable judgment on that $200k but were blocked by Ibarra from getting that, and even if the Appeals court were to say that the $200k jury award was vacated correctly, then the next question would be: “Who would be entitled to get that $200k?” Hester has no standing to stand in the shoes of Lee, and if he did, Sulla has never provided any proof that Hester is the legal heir.

People ask what happened with Probate Court. Well Sulla came into the picture after we beat a malicious prosecution lawsuit and trial for judicial foreclosure because Leonard had paid the mortgage timely and had too much equity in the property.

So Sulla was not the original attorney for the seller during the trial and he suddenly appears on the case after the trial, and goes to Probate court and tells the court the truth that his client Lee (the original seller) lost the judicial foreclosure to us and is out of the case, since has no more interest in the property. So the case was closed. Or so we thought.




All the while Sulla is concocting a scheme to later act like we never won and he never went to Probate court. So he finds a strawman drifter, Jason Hester, creates a fake church and makes Hester the overseer, transfers our notes and mortgage into the fake church and proceeds with his scheme to steal our place with a NJF auction, like we never won the judicial foreclosure case, tells the court he is the lawyer for his “client” and then eventually this past September transferred the property to himself. I gotta write a book on how to steal a house from a crooks pov: Proven to be effective in committing Grand Theft.

Sulla stated these facts to Judge Strance in the Probate case, in order to get Strance to dismiss the probate action while fraudulently concealing Sulla’s self-appointed personal representative status now managing Lee’s estate without any court authorization that is required. Sulla was also concealing his fraudulent transfers of the mortgage and notes into GOB formed by Sulla’s forgery of Lee’s signatures on pages 6 and 8 of the Incorporation papers filed with the DCCA.

So Sulla filed for quiet title in this current case that is the latest case wherein Ibarra and his subordinates are railroading us (0304) concealing Sulla’s torts and crimes. Instead of getting any kind of justice, we got hammered, censored, and deprived of our due process rights. Again Sulla or Hester never got questioned, even though the burden of proof was on them to prove the strength of their title. We attempted to remove the case to U.S. Federal court, and Judge Seabright remanded it after assistant Judge Richard L. Puglisi disqualified Sulla as a necessary witness at trial. WHAT TRIAL? We never had a triall. We were completely shut down so the Court could deliver our property to Sulla.

Stephen WAfter Sulla was disqualified, it was Stephen Whittaker that Sulla hired to represent Hester. Not once did anyone question how a homeless drifter can afford two high priced lawyers. It was obvious and now confirmed by our attorney that Sulla is the one paying Whittaker.

Whittaker appeared to have a close relationship with Judge Strance. They are both part of the small LGBT community in Kona. Strance was leaving the bench and she did her friend a favor. The first thing they did was challenge our standing, to divert from challenging Plaintiff Hester’s standing, which is a violation, since the burden of proof was on Hester not us. They claimed since Leonard’s Corporation sole, was on the original mortgage, we had no standing, and no standing to defend the Corporation either, without a lawyer. Even though, Leonard and I were named as individuals in the lawsuit, and even though Leonard’s signature was on the original promissory note, and even though Leonard brought in a lawyer to vacate the default on our ministry, and even though 2 years prior to this current case, we had transferred all interests from the Corporation Sole into our personal names, and then dissolved the corporation sole, because Sulla kept maliciously suing it.  The corporation sole no longer had any interest in the property, we did! All mortgage payments were paid timely (we have the check receipts) and were signed by Leonard. It was his money. Also HRS 419-8 and Washington statutes 24.12.010 and 24.12.020 gave Leonard standing to defend his property, in the “winding up” period of the corporate sole.

By taking our standing away, it was like our case no longer had any legs.

The 0304 judgment is void, because: (1) not once did Hester ever put in one affidavit or even have to come to court to testify. That means there were no facts before the court to rule in favor of Hester. In other words, the court lacked “subject matter jurisdiction;” and (2) Hester’s name was not on the note. That means he had no standing and the court had no “personal jurisdiction.” All that means is that the final judgment granting Hester quiet title to our property is VOID.

Fake Hester family hides faces leaving courthouseWhittaker filed for Summary Judgment, and Ibarra took over the case from Strance. For the Summary Judgment, Whittaker brought in a fake Hester (see attached photographs of the imposter!) The imposter came with a fake family to gain Ibarra’s sympathy. I told the judge that Hester was not in the courtroom, but he ignored it.

We attempted to get Ibarra disqualified for bias around this time, but he denied our request. We knew that he was violating our rights to due process, and of res judicata, but Ibarra kept saying that he was doing this because of the NJF foreclosure, and we kept telling him that the NJF was void because it violated 667-5, and because Sulla had no right to foreclose, and his church had no right, since he had not formed it yet when he transferred our notes and mortgage via forgeries into GOB, and Sulla has no right to use Hester as an heir when he was not. Especially since Lee had a son and also a sister he chose to live with in Arizona when he died, that he would have left a Will for, if he had any entitlement or interest in the subject property left. We kept asking Ibarra how come Sulla and Hester were never questioned about their standing or about the forgeries, or about violating 667-5, or 651-C and the judge never addressed it with us or bothered to question Hester or Sulla. The fact alone that Ibarra allowed Hester to substitute for Lee was an outrage, without Hester ever being made to prove anything. Sulla either had Ibarra, Strance, and Fujino completely conned; or they knew what they were doing to purposely aid-and-abet Sulla’s theft.

Judge Ibarra never blinked an eye when our Attorney Margaret Wille put in filings and pleaded that this was an illegal cheme, involving forgeries, and that Hester was a shill. Click Click Here is a video of that hearing.
Also below is Sulla’s money laundering enterprise chart. He created trusts and LLCs to hide the income for tax evasion involving more than 50 properties, while concealing his own interests.


The name “ROBERTOSILVA,” is actually two names combined to conceal Sulla’s Ayahusca (DMT) drug enterprise. If you separate the names “Roberto” and “Silva” and put the name like that in the search, you see the connnection to ayahuasca and DMT commerce. Sulla also writes the church name like this because his local DMT manufacturing business is illegal.

Here is an incident that happened in Sulla’s drug church where a man had a life threatening accident after being given Ayahuasca by Sulla’s “church” officials.

Finally, Judge Ibarra replaced himself in our case, with a new Circuit Court Judge named Melvin Fujino who has now signed off on a Writ of Ejectment on a property Leonard paid for with his life savings. The Writ of Ejectment was stamped on the 1st of March but sneakily delivered on our gate on the night of March 12th, and not entered on the Ho’ohiki court record until March 11th, and never sent to our attorney Margaret Wille or to us. This delay in allowing us to receive it, also prejudiced us in filing an opposition. Currently, the ejectment is at the Hilo Sheriff’s department, and Attorney Wille was told by a deputy that Sulla is the one that is pushing for it to be served. Attorney Wille told the sheriff that Sulla has been disqualified from representing Hester so Sulla has no right to be in correspondence with the sheriff’s office in this matter. Margaret Wille is an esteemed County Councilwoman on the Big Island, and is responsible for helping pass the ethics bills. She sees something seriously wrong with what is going on in the Third Circuit Court. In the photo above, she is questioning Mayor Billy Kenoi, who was later indicted on multiple counts of thievery and perjury.

Leonard had filed for Chapter 13 Bankruptcy because the property is necessary for reorganization, since all of our current debt comes from our legal fees regarding the subject property. If we were able to regain our title back and open up the inn to business, then we would have been able to pay back our attorneys fees. Unfortunately Bankruptcy Judge Robert Faris, stated he would not go against the state court in any way. So the Automatic Stay granted in Bankruptcy court was granted, which gave Sulla the opportunity to move forward with his theft scheme.

On June 10, 2016, Paul J. Sulla Jr. trespassed onto our property with a group of others including a realtor named Lori Enriques, and they broke into our house, intimidating our land caretaker. Sulla even had a locksmith change the locks. The police were called and he was removed. He claimed that the sheriff’s were taking too long to come. Our neighbor called the police and took these photos.



The local Hilo sheriff’s would not come and and evict us, so Paul J. Sulla hired a corrupt sheriff from Maui named Patrick Sniffen. He flew him over to the Big Island and allegedly paid him big bucks to come onto our property on July 7th, 2016, when no one was home, break in, and he handed our property over to a realtor commissioned by Sulla named Lori Enriques. Enriques works under Paul J. Sulla’s friend, Gregg Gadd at Big Island Land Company in Hilo. Lori Enriques currently resides on our stolen property.

This unlawful eviction that robbed us of our home, was not done by any bank. Our property was actually handed to a white collar crime gang.  This group includes drug dealers that have been terrorizing us for a long time. While we had possession, Paul J. Sulla never set foot on the property. Today he refuses to care for the property and is likely to vandalize it. He also pays no taxes on it.

There are many fixtures such as our valuable fish ponds, fruit trees and our structures that we cannot take with us. None of these things were ever considered for their value, nor determined by any court based on the merits.

We continue to pay the taxes for it, or the county threatened that it would go to auction it, regardless of our predicament.

We pray that eventually we will have a fair judge in the justice system that can help us stop this malicious prosecution and property theft, and prevent these devil-doers from harming anyone else.


UPDATE in SEPTEMBER Paul J Sulla covertly transferred our property to himself.  He still telling the courts he is just the lawyer for his “client’ and has no interests in our property.




















Paul J. Sulla Jr’s Illegal Ayahuasca Drug Church Operation believed to be used for theft of Real Property and Money Laundering:


BREG Online Services – Sulla’s Church

BREG Online Services – Sulla’sChurchOfficer

Incident at Sulla’s Drug Church

Further Drug Church Evidence

This is the website for Sulla’s drug church:

See further evidence in graphics at the bottom of the page


Some Other Victims of Paul J. Sulla, Jr’s drug church and other crimes.:



Affidavits of Anonymous Parties

AFFIDAVIT OF Fred and Marj Dente_Victims of Sulla


The Many Hats worn by Paul J. Sulla, Jr.:

Hats Worn By Sulla


Proof that Sulla admitted that Lee had no more interest in the property because he Lee had lost in a foreclosure to Leonard:

Estate of Cecil Loran Lee


Sulla’s illegal 50K Mortgage to Hester on our property:



Letter and Tax Records proving that the church Sulla created to non-judicially foreclose in order to steal our property was a fraud:

Ritke Letter To Jason Hester

Tax Office Records of Fraud Ritke, Hester


Affidavit of Private Investigator proving that Jason Hester is not blood related to Seller Cecil Loran Lee, as Paul J. Sulla, Jr claimed. Sulla claimed that Hester was Lee’s nephew, and then later after this affidavit from the PI, changed his story and claimed Hester was Lee’s grandnephew.

Affidavit of Christopher Baker BSIS


Affidavit of Handwriting Expert Beth Chrisman proving Sulla forged the Mortgage and notes by copy and paste in order to transfer them from Leonard and his Corporation Sole The Royal Bloodline of David to a church that did not yet exist.



Declaration of Handwriting Expert Beth Chrisman proving Sulla forged the signature or Process Server, Robert Ducat as RDUM.



Attorney Margaret Wille’s Letter to Judge Ibarra regarding his delay of signing the 5th Amended final judgment in 0196, while he allowed the 0304 to fly by.

Attorney Margaret Wille’s Letter to Judge Ronald Ibarra 3-3-16


Hoohiki Record proving that on 3/17/16, Attorney Wille’s request for the process of the 5th Amended final judgment, had still not been signed, 2 months later.

Hawai`i State Judiciary: Ho`ohiki_03_17_2016


Attorney Whittaker lies to Circuit Court Judge Melvin Fujino on 2/26/15 regarding his knowledge that he was given 10 days by Judge Ronald Ibarra to respond. On 10/30/15, he clearly acknowledged to the judge a few times, that he had 10 days.

The Judge allows Whittaker to get away with this, and even signs off on a Writ of Ejectment 3 days later, giving our property to Jason Hester (but really to Paul J. Sulla, Jr. who is the concealed real party of interest)




These are the two Conflicting Final Judgments. Sulla lied to the Bankruptcy Judge Faris and told him there was not 2 conflicting judgments.

5th Amended Final Judgment stamped March 4th, 2016 that states that judicial foreclosure was denied, and Leonard prevailed after jury trial, and that the final balloon payment of the mortgage had been paid. (See page 5 Footnote 1)



Conflicting Final Judgment that gives away subject property Dec 30, 2015, to Jason Hester with no questions asked of Hester and no trial ever involving him or Sulla.

Final Judgment_0304


Writ of Ejectment stamped by clerk of Judge Melvin Fujino on March 1st, and posted to our gate on March 12th, to prejudice us in responding to it timely.

Paul J. Sulla Jr’s handwriting is on the document over words that are crossed out and not initialed.

Sulla was disqualified from representing Hester in this case, but still continues to attempt to steal our home and land.


Writ Of Ejectment (1) court stamped 3-1-16 and posted on gate on 3-12-16

Note: The Writ of Ejectment above states by the clerk that it is a true copy of the original, and even though it was stamped by the court, it is not filed with the court.

The Writ below is what is actually filed with the court and instead of a stamp, it has Judge Melvin Fujino’ signature on it. We never received a copy of this version of the Writ below until our attorney Margaret Wille went to the court and acquired it, after the suspicious way the Writ 1 was was delivered on our gate.

Note: Writ 2 below was not the Writ posted to our gate, even though the Writ posted on our gate says “True and Original copy.”

We believe that Writ 2 below was created by Judge Fujino to cover up the fact that disqualified and concealed real party of interest, Paul J. Sulla Jr’s  handwriting was on the Writ posted on our gate. This is more evidence that Judge Melvin Fujino is complicit with Paul J. Sulla, Jr. Notice the different handwritten where the words are crossed out on both documents. How can the court claim that one is copy of the other?



This is the comparison chart timeline of the Writ of Ejectment.

Writ of Ejectment Comparison Table w- Writs 1 & 2

Attorney Margaret Wille’s letter to the Judge Fujino regarding the violation of our rights in the court including with the manner in which the Writ of Ejectment was issued.

Attorney Margaret Wille’s Letter to Judge Fujino 3-14-16


Attorney Wille’s Motion to Stay the Writ of Ejectment, where again she states that our 14th Amendment rights are being violated.

Defendants Emergency Motion for Stay of Writ of Ejectment 3-14-16


Attorney Margaret Wille’s Motion for Continuance which was denied. In this motion she states the same thing she has been attempting to tell both Judge Ibarra and now Judge Fujino that this is a scheme and a hoax to steal our property based on Paul J. Sulla’s forgeries:

Motion for Continuance Complete 5-9-16


Out of 6000 pages on the 0196 Appeals record, 6 of the pages in different section were whited out, and all of the whiting out happens to be the handwriting of Judge Glenn Hara when he was Attorney Glenn Hara of Stanley Roehrig’s lawfirm, Roehrig, Roehrig, Wilson & Hara.

It is believed that Judge Ronald Ibarra was involved in the tampering of evidence to cover up Judge Glenn Hara’s malpractice and involvement in what took place in the case.


In an unrelated case regarding the unlawful TMT project, now suddenly referred to as “TIO,”  Attorney Stanley Roehrig, who is also a member of the BLNR is  allegedly involved in a criminal no-disclosure scandal for failure to disclose information regarding compromising relations and seemingly over $70,000 of conflict of interest, with so-called “PUEO” President Shadd Keahi Warfield.

Mehana Kihoi is defending the sacred Mauna Kea mountain from TMT, and she recently put in a 118 page Memorandum & Motion for RECONSIDERATION TO DENY THE INTERVENTION OF PERPETUATING UNIQUE EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES AS A PARTY.

The motion of reconsideration stems from the appearance of new and pertinent information.

“PUEO should be denied intervention as a party to the contested case because new and relevant information presented demonstrates the President of PUEO, Shadd Keahi Warfield, has a financial conflict of interest to BLNR member Stanley Roehrig.”

“Roehrig received thousands of dollars in tax exemptions due to his business relationship with Warfield.”

Roehrig filed a so-called disclosure failing to profess any of this information.

Attorney Stanley Roehrig was also involved in censorship of public documents in 2006 in an unrelated case.


Now back to more evidence in our case against Paul J. Sulla, Jr….


 Adversarial Complaint within Chapter 13 Bankruptcy:

Adversary Proceeding Complaint March 9 2015 w-Exhibits and stamped


Motion in Adversarial Complaint that proves Sulla violated the Bankruptcy Automatic Stay:

Motion for TRO Stay Extension and Exhibits 3-18-2016


Sulla’s Motion to Lift the Automatic Stay in bankruptcy Court which is filled with lies and omissions:

Motion for Relief of Stay Sulla 3-21-16


Leonard’s response to Hester/Sulla Motion to Lift the Stay

Memorandum in Reply to Motion for Relief of Stay w: Exhibits stamped 3-28-16


Sulla’s response to Leonard’s response to Lifting the Stay which includes lies and Omissions again including the claim that there is a tax auction scheduled for June 3o, 2016 and Sulla also falsely claims that there are not 2 conflicting final judgments.

Hester’sResponsetoResponsetoStay 4-2-16
Motion by Leonard filed against Paul J. Sulla, Jr.

Reply to Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction and Extended Stay [FRBP Rule 7065; FRCP Rule 65; and FRCP Rule 8(b)(6)]. Filed by Plaintiff Leonard G. Horowitz.






More of Paul J. Sulla’s lies to Federal Bankruptcy court.

Supplemental Pleading for Injunctive Relief Hearing on April 29, 2016, Pursuant to Bad Faith Filing of Declaration of Paul J. Sulla Jr. Served Untimely . Filed by Plaintiff Leonard G. Horowitz



More proof that Sulla lied to the bankruptcy court Judge Faris by his false claims that there is a pending tax sale if county property taxes are not paid in full by June 30th. This is a letter from the county tax office confirming that our property is not scheduled for a tax auction.

Letter from The Hawaii County Tax Office


Our Agreement with the Hawaii County tax office since Sulla transferred the taxes out of Leonard’s name:

Tax Office Agreement 4-8-13


Sulla violates Automatic Bankruptcy Stay by requesting Attorneys Fees and Costs in another Appeals case:

Request and Declaration of Counsel for Attorneys’ Fees and Costs 3-11-16


Len’s response to Sulla’s request for Attorney Fees and Costs:

Appellant Opposition to Request for Fees and Costs with Exhibits 1 to 11 Filed 3-15-16


Video Motion to Disqualify Judge Ronald Ibarra- Check this video out, it is a stunner!


Hilo Prosecutor Mitch Roth refuses to investigate Paul J. Sulla, Jr. falsely claiming that the statute of limitations were up in 2004, even though Paul J. Sulla came into the picture in 2009 to steal. 

2004 was when the Seller, Loren Lee was first reported.  Sulla has extended Lee’s crimes, which are ongoing, so this letter was written in bad faith.

Prosecutors Letter to Horowitz 10-26-15

Federal Grand Jury Activated in Hawaii Investigates Government Corruption and Murder


Retired Homicide Detective Jim Benish’s letter to the U.S Attorney in Hawaii regarding our case:

Jim Benish letter to Justice Department


Response letter rom the Judicial Conduct Committee after submitting a complaint to them about Judge Ronald Ibarra and Judge Fujino.

Response from Hawaii judicial Committee


Screen Shot 2016-06-16 at 11.35.17 PM










Letter to the Attorney General of Hawaii regarding Sulla’s forgeries aided and abetted by Collins Tomei, a notary and bank manager for Territorial Savings in Hilo, Hawaii, and also a Third Circuit Officer. (the same court that gave Sulla our property, with disregard for his confirmed forgeries and without giving us a trial, Violating our 14th Amendment rights.

letter-to-dep-attorney-wong-w-exhibits-1-9-10-20-16 signature-comparisons1


Photos of the Paul J. Sulla, Jr. (center) Jason Hester (right) and Hester imposter (left and also bottom photo right.) The imposter and along with Sulla’s secretary, Lokie White and a fake family for the Hester impersonator (bottom right seen covering their faces) were brought to court by Sulla’s attorney, Stephen Whittaker (bottom photo left).







Paul J Sulla's illegal Ayahuasca drug church on a 67 acre Compound used as part of his real estate enterprise and believe to be part of his money laundering operation

Paul J. Sulla’s Jr’s Illegal Ayahuasca Drug Church congregation. Paul J. Sulla conceals himself in this photo. (He can be seen: far right, between rows 1 & 2, the only one with dark sunglasses on)


Letter to Police 6-11-16 for Police Report regarding Paul J. Sulla, Jr. breaking into our home.

Affidavit of Witness 1 to the break in

Affidavit of Witness 2 to the break in


The Hilo Sheriff department refused to come and evict us because they knew it was not right. So Sulla once again decided to take matters into his own hands and he hired a Maui Sheriff- Patrick Sniffen to come and evict our land caretaker, Clay since we were on off island.  So on July 6, 2016, Clay was not home at the time, so Sniffen trespassed through our locked gates, and walked right into our home. I tried to call Clay after a friend called to tell me that there was a black SUV blocking our driveway. Sniffen answered our phone when I called, and told me who he was, and then hung up on me when I asked why he was in my home. We contacted the police for assistance and instead of assisting us, they assisted Sniffen in handing over our home to Sulla’s cronies including his realtor, Lori Enriquez, and Sulla’s subordinate process server, Robert Dukat of Pyramid process. I tried calling the house again and this time Lori Enriquez answered the phone and said that we no longer had possession.


We followed up with the original cop that told Sulla to leave the property, Officer Walker and we captured the conversation of him and his supervisor Sargeant Essension on audio. They give us the lame excuse, it’s all a civil matter once again:



This is the latest filing by our attorney Margaret Wille in response to Paul J. Sulla Jr. attempting to evade responding to our Appeals brief, by requesting that the court allow him a 3rd extension




Other Stories regarding the corruption of Paul J. Sulla, Jr:

Paul J. Sulla Jr. set up a trust for Hawaii’s largest gun dealer, Arthur Lee Ong. He told Ong that the trust was legal. Sulla was named in the superceding indictment. Sulla walked, and Ong and 3 other went to prison:

Star Advertiser Article

United States of America v. Arthur Lee Ong


Paul J. Sulla lived on Kauai in the 90’s before the Big Island, and there was a nice woman that wanted to start a community radio station. Her name was Janet Friend. She got people to donate to make it happen including the late Glenn Frey who donated 50K. Sulla smelled money coming in from some other infiltrator, and he highjacked the stations and transferred everything into his name illegally and took the money. Janet was so upset she developed stomach cancer and died. She was only in her 40’s. This is a video before she died with Sulla when he was younger lying and scheming.

Click Here for the Affidavit of two of the victims in this Kauai radio highjacking crime



Survey Says … Hawaii Is Corrupt!

Attorney Paul J Sulla involved in Real Property Theft

Click to add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Civil Rights

Hawaii Challenge to Trump Travel Ban Vets Pattern of Judicial Corruption and Mob Rule Over “Paradise”

adminApril 22, 2017


adminApril 10, 2017

Nancy J. Budd

admJuly 20, 2015

Hawaii Third Circuit Court Steeped in Fraud and Crime

adminJuly 11, 2015

Florida voters protest judicial psychopathology!

admNovember 24, 2014